Are We Accommodating Students With ADHD—or Actually Helping Them Learn?

A new study from Florida International University challenges some of the most common classroom accommodations used for students with ADHD. The findings raise important questions about what effective educational support should look like.

Extra time on assignments. Frequent breaks. A quieter place to work. Permission to stand instead of sit.

For years, these have been among the most familiar accommodations recommended for students with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). They appear regularly in Individualized Education Programs (IEPs), Section 504 plans, psychological evaluations, and recommendations provided to teachers and parents.

The reasoning behind them seems sensible. If a student struggles to concentrate, reduce distractions. If completing assignments takes longer, provide additional time. If sitting still is difficult, allow movement.

But what if some of these accommodations aren't actually improving the student's academic performance?

A new randomized clinical trial published on November 13, 2026, in JAMA Pediatrics raises precisely that question. Researchers at Florida International University's Center for Children and Families examined four commonly used classroom accommodations and found that none produced statistically significant improvements in the academic or behavioral outcomes they measured.

The findings are important, but they require careful interpretation. They do not establish that accommodations are unnecessary or that students with ADHD should be expected to succeed without support. Rather, they challenge a longstanding assumption: that changing the conditions under which a student completes schoolwork necessarily improves the student's ability to learn and perform.

For parents, educators, and professionals involved in educational planning, this distinction deserves serious consideration.

What the Researchers Actually Studied

The study, led by psychologist Gregory Fabiano and colleagues, involved 255 children with ADHD who began participating in Florida International University's Summer Treatment Program between 2022 and 2025. The children were enrolled in kindergarten through sixth grade, with an average age of approximately nine years.

Rather than simply asking teachers or parents whether particular accommodations seemed helpful, the researchers used a randomized crossover design. Children experienced different classroom conditions, allowing investigators to examine how their performance changed when specific interventions were introduced.

Four accommodations were tested:

  • Extended time to complete assignments.

  • Frequent breaks during classroom work.

  • A low-distraction workspace.

  • Permission to stand while working at a desk.

The researchers also examined behavioral interventions and stimulant medication, both independently and in combination with the accommodations.

Outcomes included classroom rule violations, the number of academic problems completed correctly, and quiz performance.

The results were striking. None of the four accommodations significantly improved the measured classroom outcomes, even when they were combined with behavioral interventions or medication.

By comparison, behavioral interventions and stimulant medication produced measurable improvements.

The study found that behavioral interventions reduced classroom rule violations during independent work by approximately 37%, while stimulant medication reduced them by approximately 61%. Medication also increased academic productivity by approximately 22% and improved quiz scores by an average of 3.9 points.

These findings do not mean that medication is necessarily the appropriate choice for every child, nor that behavioral interventions and medication serve identical purposes. Treatment decisions must be individualized and involve appropriately qualified professionals.

What the results do suggest is that interventions designed to change specific behaviors and support academic performance may accomplish something that simply modifying classroom conditions does not.

Why Extra Time Might Not Be Enough

Consider a student who regularly struggles to finish classroom assignments.

A common recommendation is to provide additional time. If the student cannot complete an assignment within 30 minutes, perhaps allowing 45 minutes will solve the problem.

Sometimes that may be appropriate. A student who understands the material but works slowly because of a disability-related limitation may benefit from additional time.

But consider a different student whose difficulty involves initiating tasks, organizing information, maintaining attention, or returning to work after becoming distracted.

Providing another 15 minutes does not necessarily address any of those difficulties.

The student may continue to struggle with the same problems, only over a longer period.

This illustrates an important distinction between removing a barrier and developing a skill.

An accommodation generally changes how a task is presented, completed, or accessed. An instructional or behavioral intervention may directly teach or reinforce the behaviors necessary to perform that task.

Both approaches can be appropriate, but they are not interchangeable.

If a student has difficulty organizing written assignments, providing additional time may reduce pressure. However, explicit instruction in breaking assignments into smaller steps, establishing a sequence, monitoring progress, and checking completed work may more directly address the difficulty.

The central question should be whether the support matches the reason the student is struggling.

The Difference Between Accommodations and Interventions

This is where I believe the study has particular relevance for educational evaluations.

An accommodation is intended to provide access or reduce the impact of a disability-related barrier. It does not necessarily teach the student a new skill.

An intervention is designed to improve a particular behavior, skill, or area of functioning.

For example, allowing a student to take frequent breaks may help manage fatigue, restlessness, or sensory demands. But if the primary concern is difficulty completing assignments, the student may also need structured goals, task initiation strategies, consistent feedback, and reinforcement for completing work.

Similarly, providing a quieter environment may reduce competing distractions without necessarily improving the student's ability to organize information, follow multistep directions, or independently monitor performance.

These distinctions are particularly relevant for students with ADHD because the diagnosis can involve different combinations of inattention, impulsivity, hyperactivity, and executive-functioning difficulties.

Two students with the same diagnosis may experience very different educational challenges.

One may understand classroom material but struggle to initiate assignments. Another may complete work quickly but make frequent careless errors. A third may have difficulty following instructions, managing materials, or regulating behavior during group activities.

Recommending the same accommodations for all three students may overlook the differences that should guide their educational support.

What Worked Better in the Study?

The behavioral interventions examined by the researchers emphasized clear expectations, positive feedback, reinforcement, and consistent classroom management.

One approach involved a daily report card, which allows teachers to establish individualized behavioral goals, monitor performance, and provide regular feedback.

For example, rather than simply telling a student to remain focused, a teacher might establish a measurable goal involving beginning work promptly, completing a defined portion of an assignment, or following directions during a particular classroom period.

The student receives feedback about progress and positive reinforcement for meeting the goal.

This approach makes expectations more concrete and gives the student opportunities to practice behaviors that support academic success.

The distinction is especially important because children with ADHD may know what they are supposed to do without consistently demonstrating that knowledge in everyday situations.

A student may understand the importance of completing assignments but struggle to begin them. Another may recognize classroom rules but have difficulty regulating behavior when frustrated or distracted.

Effective intervention requires identifying the behavior or skill that needs improvement and creating opportunities to develop it.

The FIU findings support greater attention to these strategies, although the researchers did not demonstrate that every behavioral intervention improves every academic outcome. In particular, the study found improvements in classroom behavior with behavioral intervention, while medication also improved academic productivity and quiz performance.

That distinction matters when interpreting what the interventions actually accomplished.

Does This Mean Schools Should Stop Providing ADHD Accommodations?

No. That would be an overly broad interpretation of the research.

The study examined four accommodations under particular experimental conditions. It did not evaluate every accommodation available to students with ADHD, nor did it establish that these supports can never benefit an individual student.

The research was conducted within a structured summer treatment program rather than across an ordinary academic year. Accommodations changed frequently, and the researchers acknowledged that some students may respond differently depending on their individual characteristics.

It is also important to recognize that the study measured specific classroom outcomes. An accommodation might serve another legitimate purpose, such as reducing distress, improving physical comfort, or providing equitable access, even if it does not produce a measurable improvement in quiz scores or assignment completion during a short observation period.

Furthermore, the absence of a statistically significant average benefit does not prove that every student experienced no benefit.

The findings do, however, challenge the routine use of accommodations without sufficient consideration of whether they are helping.

If a student has received extended time for several years but continues to struggle with completing assignments, it may be time to examine whether additional time is addressing the actual problem.

If frequent breaks have not improved classroom participation, the team should consider whether the breaks are being used appropriately, whether another intervention is needed, or whether the student's difficulty has been misunderstood.

The appropriate response is not to eliminate accommodations indiscriminately. It is to evaluate their purpose and effectiveness.

What This Means for IEPs and Section 504 Plans

IEPs and Section 504 plans are intended to address students' individual educational needs. They should not function as standardized lists of accommodations assigned solely because a student has a particular diagnosis.

A student with ADHD may qualify for protections and services under Section 504, and some students may qualify for special education under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA).

The legal requirements governing those supports remain in effect regardless of the findings of a particular research study.

The U.S. Department of Education has emphasized that decisions about Section 504 services must be individualized and informed by appropriate evaluation information. Schools cannot simply rely on generalizations about what students with a particular diagnosis need.

This is where the new research becomes especially relevant.

An IEP or 504 plan may contain accommodations that were recommended years earlier and continued without much discussion. Over time, the student's academic demands, abilities, and support needs may change.

An accommodation that was useful in elementary school may no longer address the primary difficulty in middle school. Conversely, increasing academic complexity may create new needs that were not apparent previously.

Educational planning should therefore involve more than confirming that the student continues to receive the accommodations listed in the plan.

Teams should consider whether those supports are effective, whether additional interventions are needed, and whether the student's current functioning supports revising the approach.

A well-written plan is important. But its value ultimately depends on whether the student receives meaningful support and can access the educational opportunities to which they are entitled.

The Importance of Understanding Why a Student Is Struggling

One of the most useful lessons from this research is that similar academic difficulties can have very different causes.

Consider three students who regularly fail to complete written assignments.

The first has difficulty sustaining attention and frequently becomes distracted.

The second struggles with reading comprehension and does not fully understand the instructions.

The third understands the assignment but has difficulty organizing ideas and producing a written response.

All three may appear to have the same problem: incomplete schoolwork.

But their educational needs are different.

The first student may benefit from structured behavioral supports and frequent feedback. The second may need targeted reading instruction or assistance understanding written directions. The third may require explicit writing instruction, organizational strategies, or appropriate assistive technology.

Simply providing additional time to all three students may overlook the underlying reasons for their difficulties.

This is why educational and learning support evaluations should examine more than diagnostic labels. Academic achievement, learning processes, attention, executive functioning, adaptive behavior, and performance in everyday educational activities may all provide useful information.

Academic achievement, learning processes, attention, executive functioning, adaptive behavior, and performance in everyday educational activities may all provide useful information.

The purpose is not to collect as many test scores as possible. It is to understand how the student functions and identify supports that address meaningful barriers.

In my work involving educational and vocational assessment, this distinction is fundamental. As I've discussed previously, a diagnosis does not tell us what someone can actually do. A diagnosis may explain why certain difficulties are more likely to occur, but it does not establish how those difficulties affect a particular person's performance or which intervention will be most effective.

What Parents Should Ask at the Next IEP or 504 Meeting

For parents whose children already receive ADHD accommodations, the new study offers an opportunity to ask more specific questions about the support being provided.

Rather than focusing exclusively on whether an accommodation is listed in the plan, parents can ask what difficulty it is intended to address and how the team determines whether it is working.

For example, if a child receives extended time, does the additional time result in more completed work, better accuracy, or less frustration? If the student receives frequent breaks, is there evidence that the breaks improve participation or the ability to return to work?

Parents can also ask whether the student is receiving direct instruction or behavioral support for difficulties involving organization, task initiation, attention, or self-monitoring.

These discussions should be collaborative and informed by the student's educational data, classroom observations, and individual circumstances.

It may be useful to establish specific goals and review progress over time. When an accommodation is not producing the intended benefit, the team can consider adjustments or additional interventions.

Parents should not interpret the study as a reason to discontinue an existing IEP or 504 accommodation without an individualized review. A student's legal entitlement to appropriate supports is not determined by whether an accommodation produced an average benefit in one research study.

The goal is to make educational planning more responsive to the student's actual needs.

A Broader Lesson About Disability Support

Although this study focused on elementary school students with ADHD, it raises a question that extends beyond the classroom.

In disability services, we often concentrate on identifying accommodations and supports. That is necessary, but it can sometimes become an end in itself.

The presence of an accommodation does not automatically demonstrate that a barrier has been effectively addressed.

The same principle applies to vocational rehabilitation, employment support, and adult education.

A workplace accommodation may improve access to a job without teaching the employee a skill they have not yet developed. Conversely, training may improve skills without removing an environmental barrier that prevents someone from performing effectively.

Neither approach is inherently superior. Their value depends on the person's needs and the demands of the activity.

For students preparing for adulthood, this distinction becomes particularly important, especially when planning for life after high school. Academic accommodations may help a student access classroom instruction and demonstrate knowledge. At the same time, students may need opportunities to develop organization, self-direction, problem-solving, communication, and other skills that will become increasingly important in postsecondary education, employment, and independent living.

Academic accommodations may help a student access classroom instruction and demonstrate knowledge. At the same time, students may need opportunities to develop organization, self-direction, problem-solving, communication, and other skills that will become increasingly important in postsecondary education, employment, and independent living.

A comprehensive approach should recognize both needs.

We should provide appropriate accommodations where they are necessary while also helping individuals develop the skills and strategies that support greater independence.

Support Should Be Measured by What It Accomplishes

The new FIU study does not provide a reason to abandon ADHD accommodations. It provides a reason to examine them more carefully.

Its most important contribution may be the reminder that familiar recommendations are not necessarily effective simply because they are widely used.

Extended time, frequent breaks, standing desks, and low-distraction environments may sound appropriate for students with ADHD. But the researchers found no statistically significant average improvement in the classroom outcomes they examined.

Meanwhile, interventions that directly addressed classroom behavior produced measurable benefits, and stimulant medication improved both behavior and academic performance on the study's measures.

The findings reinforce the importance of individualized assessment, evidence-based intervention, and ongoing evaluation of educational progress.

For parents and educators, the question should not simply be whether a student has accommodations.

It should be whether those accommodations address the student's needs, whether additional instruction or intervention is necessary, and whether the student is making meaningful progress.

Because providing support and producing improvement are not always the same thing.

And students with ADHD deserve educational plans that do more than look appropriate on paper.

References

Fabiano, G. A., Merrill, B. M., Gallo, R. F., et al. (2026). Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder accommodations, behavior therapy, and stimulant medication: A randomized clinical trial. JAMA Pediatrics. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamapediatrics.2026.5973

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2024). ADHD in the classroom. https://www.cdc.gov/adhd/treatment/classroom.html

U.S. Department of Education, Office for Civil Rights. (2016). Dear colleague letter and resource guide on students with ADHD and Section 504. https://www.ed.gov/sites/ed/files/about/offices/list/ocr/letters/colleague-201607-504-adhd.pdf

U.S. Department of Education, Office for Civil Rights. (2016). Parent and educator resource guide to Section 504 in public elementary and secondary schools. https://www.ed.gov/sites/ed/files/about/offices/list/ocr/docs/504-resource-guide-201612.pdf

Next
Next

If Vocational Rehabilitation Can Work, Why Is Florida Still Struggling to Deliver?